Backlog
pending
Rui Ferreira
tickets (8)
2014-03-12
2013-05-23
Carla Leite
No
0 up votes | 0 down votes | 0%
7 comments

When you try to edit a Ticket, besides the description textbox and options, the reply box is still there. That reply box should disappear, like comments do.

Discussion

  • Rui Ferreira
    Rui Ferreira
    2013-05-23

    Hi,

    The reply box is there so that you can edit a ticket and change the ticket status in a single operation. For example I am now closing this ticket and changing its status to 'wont-fix' through the edit form :D.

     
  • Rui Ferreira
    Rui Ferreira
    2013-05-23

    • status: open --> wont-fix
     
  • Carla Leite
    Carla Leite
    2013-05-24

    Ok, in that case yes. But still: if you are editing a comment, you shouldn't see 2 textboxs in the screen. Try to edit this, and see what happens.

     
  • Carla Leite
    Carla Leite
    2013-05-24

    • status: wont-fix --> pending
     
  • Carla Leite
    Carla Leite
    2013-05-24

    • summary: Edit Ticket: reply box should disappear --> Edit Comment: reply box should disappear
     
  • Rui Ferreira
    Rui Ferreira
    2013-05-24

    Hi,

    There is no way for you to distinguish between the two cases:

    • If you only want to make a comment, you don't press the edit button
    • If you want to edit the ticket itself, the reply is there -> and it should be the

    There is no way for the page to guess that you want to edit the ticket but you don't want to post a reply. And since you cannot separate the action of editing the ticket status and editing the ticket description, this really a wont-fix.

     
    Last edit: Carla Leite 2013-05-24
    • Rui Ferreira
      Rui Ferreira
      2013-05-24

      Ok, it seems I misunderstood before, you want the Comment text box at the bottom of the page to disappear, when you are editing another comment.

      Looks like we will have to take a look at the Javascript from the allura theme for that.